Don't want to be like your dad was?
You swore you'd never use that voice. Then one night it comes out of your mouth, word for word, and your kid looks at you the way you used to look at him.
Where he shows up, by age
When they're little
With a toddler it's often his tone: the bark, the long sigh, “because I said so.” Or the flip side. A dad who was raised hard may hardly ever say no, and then the no comes out too late and too loud, sounding just like his own father.
When they're in grade school
Your kid is now an age you can still remember being, so it can hit hard. How he talked about grades, about sports, about crying. You hear yourself say the line he used on you, and for a second you're nine again, on the other side of it.
When they're teenagers
It's the arguments. Maybe he shut you down the moment you talked back, and now your teenager talks back and you feel the same door slam inside you. Or he wasn't around, and you're not sure what a dad of a teenager is meant to do, so you hold back when they need you to step in.
Why his moves come out first
You learned how to be a father mostly by watching one, long before you could choose what to keep. Those habits come out fastest under pressure, when you're tired or angry and there's no time to think. That doesn't mean you're turning into him. It means your first move under stress is the oldest one you know, and a first move can be practiced. Plenty of men do things differently from their fathers without ever sorting out the whole past first. How not to become your father →
Three things to try this week
- Write down what you want to keep. Not just what you're running from. He may have shown up for work every day, fixed anything, never missed a game, or told a good story. Three things. It helps to know what you're keeping, too.
- Mark the moment, not the man. When you hear him in your voice this week, just note it: where you were, what your kid did, what you said. You're collecting information, not building a case against yourself.
- Give your kid one thing you didn't get. Think about what you needed from him at your kid's age. If he never said he was proud of you, say it once this week about something specific. If he never played, sit on the floor for twenty minutes. What sons learn from their dads →
When you hear him anyway
His words will come out of you some days. When they do, you don't have to finish it his way too. If he never apologized, that's the spot to do it differently: go back, say what you said, and say it wasn't fair, with no excuse tacked on. Your kid doesn't need the family history. They need to hear you own it.
If what he did still weighs on you, or if he hurt you or someone in the house, talking it through with a counselor is a reasonable step, not a dramatic one.
Write down the line your dad used when he was angry, the one you've heard yourself say or come close to. (If that doesn't fit, use any line you catch yourself saying and don't like.) Under it, write the line you want to say instead, short enough to say when you're hot. For example: "I'm getting loud. I'm going to stop and try again." With a little one, keep it to a few words. Then, when the heat comes up with your kid today, reach for your line.
That's day 10 of the program, word for word.
Relevant exercises in the program
Word for word, with their real day numbers, from the week about what fathers pass down: the chain map, and three questions for a sentence you were handed.
Open the chain map below. Fill in what you know about your grandfather, your father and yourself. "Unknown" is an honest answer, and so is "steady." If your dad wasn't around, use whoever raised you. Leave your kid's box for this evening. Watch one moment that goes wrong for your kid, and listen for your own words in their mouth. With a little one: listen to how they talk to a stuffed animal or a younger sibling when they're playing the grown-up. With an older kid: watch what they do when they lose a game or get a bad grade. Do they get loud, explain, go to their room, shrug it off? Then fill in their box, with no verdict.
Take one sentence you were handed, from your chain map or from your own mouth, and ask all three questions in writing. Is it still true? Was it ever? Who would I be if I put it down? Then, this evening, when the moment comes where that sentence would usually decide what you say to your kid, do what your answer to the third question would do, once. With a little one: if the sentence is "stop crying," try "That's sad," and give them a minute. With an older kid: if it's "don't talk back," hear their side once, all the way through, before you answer. The rule itself can stay the same. If the sentence turns out to be one you'd keep, say it to your kid on purpose.
Want one thing like this to try every day?
The Better Father is eight weeks, about ten minutes a day: a short read in the morning, one thing to try with your kids, one line in a private log before bed. Four versions by your kid's age. $149 once, no subscription. What's inside
Full refund within 14 days of buying. Just email us. You don't have to explain or show your log.
Not ready to buy? Read day five free
Guides for this one
- When you hear your father's voiceRaised by a yeller? What you picked up, and how a habit changes as it's handed down.
- Being a role model for your sonHe copies what you do more than what you say. The things he's watching.
Something else is harder right now? Take the 1-minute quiz.
This page describes a common problem, not you. It doesn't diagnose anything.