“Fine.” How to get your 6- to 12-year-old to talk to you
At five, they told you everything, whether you asked or not. Now it's “fine,” “nothing,” “I don't remember,” and back to the tablet. Here's why kids this age go quiet with their dads, and what tends to work better than asking harder.
What's hardest right now? Take the 1-minute quizFree. One thing to try tonight. No email needed.
Stop asking “how was school?” at pickup. Join something they're into for ten minutes, on their terms, and let them lead. Ask one small, specific question later, often at bedtime or in the car. When they ask about your day, give them a real answer instead of “fine.” And when they do talk, listen without fixing it or turning it into a lesson.
My son won't talk to me. Is that normal at this age?
Mostly, yes. Somewhere between about seven and twelve, kids start building a world that's theirs: friends, jokes, games, things that happened at recess that would take too long to explain. A school day is long, and “fine” at three-thirty often just means tired, or done being asked things.
It can also mean they've learned that talking to you leads somewhere they don't want to go: a lecture, a fix, a question about homework. That's worth looking at honestly. More on that below.
What's different: if your kid has pulled back from everything, not just you; if sleep, eating or school change sharply; if they've dropped friends or things they loved; or if they say anything about not wanting to be here. Then talk to their doctor or the school counselor, soon. If they're talking about hurting themselves, call or text 988 tonight.
Why doesn't “how was school?” work?
Because it's too big. To answer it, a nine-year-old would have to sum up seven hours, decide what you'd want to hear, and say it in a way that won't lead to more questions. “Fine” is easier. It's also the question every adult asks them, every day, so it gets the answer every adult gets.
Small, specific questions have a door in them. Try one, once, and not the second they get in the car:
- “Who did you sit with at lunch?”
- “What was the loudest thing that happened today?”
- “Did anybody get in trouble?”
- “What was the best part and the worst part?”
- “What's something you want to show me?”
If you get “I don't know,” let it go. Hand them a snack. Try a different one tomorrow.
Where do kids this age actually talk?
- Inside the thing they're into. The game, the drawing, the video, the Lego build. Ask them to show you how it works. You'll often hear more about their day from the side of a Minecraft world than from across the dinner table.
- In the car. Nobody has to look at anybody, and the ride has a natural end.
- At bedtime. Plenty of kids stall at lights out by finally telling you things. If you can stay five more minutes, stay.
- Over a job that needs two sets of hands. Cooking, washing the car, fixing the bike chain. Words come out around the work.
First, name your low hour: the time of day you're most likely to snap. Then give your kid ten minutes where they lead, before that hour or inside it, whichever you can manage. With a little one, get on the floor and be whatever the game needs: the customer, the monster, the bridge the cars drive over. With an older kid, ask them to show you something they're into (a game, a video, a song, a drawing). Questions are fine if they want them; skip the advice and the critique. Ten minutes. Then you're done.
If you only have them every other weekend, the same places work, and a set call time between visits helps too. Staying close to your kids after divorce →
What if what they're into bores me?
It might. That's fine. You're not there for the game; you're there because they're the one showing it to you. Ask real questions if you have them (“Wait, why did he do that?”), and skip the advice and the critique, even the friendly kind, like how they could build it better. Ten minutes. Then you're done.
Kids this age notice which of their things you're interested in. If you only ever ask about grades and chores, they figure those are the parts of them you care about.
Should I tell them about my day?
Yes. A dad who only asks questions and never answers any is running an interview. When your kid asks how your day was, give them one true sentence instead of “fine.” Keep it sized for them, and don't attach a lesson.
Once today, in a small moment with your kid, skip the act and say the plain thing instead. No joke, no command voice, no careful script. Keep it short and sized for them. With a little one: if they ask "Are you sad?" or "Are you mad?", answer straight. "A little. Not at you. I'm tired. Want to sit with me?" With an older kid: when they ask how your day was, give them one true sentence instead of "fine." "Kind of rough. I messed something up and spent the afternoon fixing it." Then let it go. Don't make it a lesson.
Stories from when you were their age work well too: the teacher you were scared of, the time you got in trouble at school. Kids tend to match what they see. Going first makes it easier for them to go second.
What do I do when they finally talk?
Keep your face calm and your mouth mostly shut. If they tell you about a bad day, “That sounds rough” is enough. Don't jump to what they should have said to the kid at recess. If they tell you something they did wrong, take a breath before you react. A kid who gets a consequence every time they tell the truth learns to stop telling it.
This is hard for most dads, because fixing is how we show we care. You can still help. Just wait until they ask, or until you've listened all the way through.
What about screens?
Start with yours. If your phone is out at dinner, theirs will be too, and anything you say about it won't land. Day 11 of the program is one line: for the two hours before your kid's bedtime, put your phone in another room. More on the phone →
What if they've stopped talking because of me?
It's worth asking. If the last few times they told you something true it ended in yelling, they'll go quiet to stay safe. That can change, and it usually starts with you going back and owning it plainly: “I yelled. That wasn't fair. You didn't deserve that.” Nothing after “but.” How to apologize to your kid → How to stop yelling →
What changes when they're a teenager?
A lot of the same things work, with more patience and fewer questions. Sitting them down for a talk backfires even more. The guide for teenagers and one-word answers →
Is it different with a daughter?
Mostly not, but a few things are worth knowing, like keeping the affection going as she grows. How to connect with your daughter →
Not sure where to start?
The free quiz for dads takes about a minute: pick what's hardest right now and get one thing to try tonight. If “fine” is the one, here's that page.