Blended Family Stepdad: Fair to Your Kids and Stepkids

The short answer

Fair doesn't mean the same for everyone; it means the same rules and the same care. Agree on one set of house rules with your partner, and let each of you lead on the bigger calls for your own kids. Give every kid some time alone with you, or with their own parent, on a schedule they can count on. When one of them says you play favorites, listen before you defend yourself. Don't ask the kids to be close; ask them to be decent to each other. And settle the hard stuff with your partner in private.

What's hardest right now? Tap the closest one to start the free quiz.

Keeping my cool when they push it Putting my phone down for them Leaving work stress at the door Getting more than “Fine.” out of them Doing it differently than my dad did Having patience left by evening

Four quick questions, about a minute. One thing to try tonight. No email needed.

More for stepdads: the main stepdad guide → · young stepkids → · teenage stepkids → · getting along with their dad →

Why is being fair so hard in a blended family?

Because every kid in the house notices who gets what, and you may too, even if you don't mean to. Your own kids have known you their whole lives. Your stepkids have known you a few years, maybe less. It can be easier to laugh off your son's mess and notice hers. Or the opposite: some dads go hard on their own kids to prove they aren't playing favorites.

Fair can't mean identical. A four-year-old and a twelve-year-old don't get the same bedtime. Fair means the same rule applies to the same thing, whoever did it, and every kid gets some of you that's theirs.

Same house rules for everyone: who enforces them, and for whom?

Sit down with your partner, without the kids, and write the house rules down. Five or six is plenty: screens, bedtimes by age, chores, how people talk to each other, what's off limits in someone else's room. Then tell all the kids together, so nobody hears it secondhand.

Everyday rules, anyone says them. “Shoes off at the door.” “Plates in the sink.” You can say it to any kid in the house, in the same voice.
Bigger calls, each parent leads on their own. Taking a phone, missing a party: that comes from you for your kids and from her for hers. When she's out and something big happens, try: “I'm going to tell your mom, and she'll handle it.”
Same thing, same answer. If your kid loses screen time for hitting, so does hers, sized to their age. If you notice you'd let it slide for one of them, don't.

My kids come every other weekend. How do I keep everyone from feeling pushed aside?

Weekend kids can feel like guests. Weekday kids can feel like they lose their dad, their stepdad, the TV and the car the minute the others arrive. Both can be true in one house.

Give your kids a place that stays theirs when they're gone: a drawer, a shelf, a bed nobody else sleeps in.
Don't cancel the stepkids' things on your weekends. If Saturday is her son's game, everyone goes, or you split up and swap next time.
Keep one regular thing with your stepkids, on your kids' weekends too, so they don't only get you when your kids are away.
Say it out loud before the weekend: “My kids are here Friday. It'll be loud. Saturday breakfast is still ours.” Then make sure it is.

If you're working out the schedule with your kids' mom, here are co-parenting tips for dads →

What do I say when a kid says I play favorites?

It may come from your daughter (“You always take her side”) or your stepson (“You'd never yell at him like that”). Don't argue it right then, and don't list everything you've done for them.

“You think I go easier on him. Tell me when.”
Listen to the whole answer. Then: “Okay. I'm going to watch for that.”
If they're right, say so: “You're right. I let it go with him and not with you. That's not fair.”

Then watch yourself for a week. Sometimes a dad has a sentence in his head about one kid, “the difficult one,” “the easy one,” and only notices what fits it. One day in the program is about exactly that.

From the program

Week 4 · Day 23The story you run on someone

What you do that day

Write the story you run on your kid in one sentence. (If you have more than one kid, pick one.) Then ask: whose voice is that? This evening, watch for one thing your kid does that the story leaves out, and say it out loud in one plain sentence, with no speech attached. With a little one: if the story is "never listens," catch the time they do. "You put your cup in the sink. Thanks." With an older kid: if the story is "lazy," find the thing they kept at, even if it's a game. "You stuck with that level for a long time."

What if the kids don't get along?

They didn't pick each other. Don't ask for love, and don't push “you're brothers now.” Ask for decency: no hitting, no taking things, no going into someone's room without asking. Same rules, same answer, whoever started it.

When it blows up, separate them first and sort out who did what later, calmly. Each parent talks to their own kid. Try: “You don't have to like sharing a room. You do have to leave his stuff alone.” Give them ways to be apart, like a second screen, different rooms, one in the yard and one inside. Try putting them side by side at something, like cooking or a project, instead of sitting them down to talk it out.

How do I get time alone with each kid?

Put it on a schedule, small and regular. Ten minutes at bedtime, the drive to practice, a Saturday errand. Your own kids need time that isn't shared with your stepkids; your stepkids need time alone with their mom, and some with you if they want it. Then say it: “Tuesday's drive is just us.”

From the program

Week 1 · Day 5Side by side, not face to face

What you do that day

Tonight, spend ten minutes side by side with your kid, doing something with your hands, and don't ask for a report on their day. With a little one: blocks, a puzzle, drawing next to them, washing the dishes together. With an older kid: an errand in the car, shooting hoops, cooking something. If they bring something up, follow it and keep your hands busy. If they don't, that's fine too. Before bed, write down three things the two of you could do over the next few weeks that need two sets of hands, and that they might actually want to do.

What do I tell my kids about my stepkids, and the other way around?

To your own kids, the thing they may be wondering and not saying: “I'm still your dad. Living with them doesn't change that.” And: “You don't have to like them like a brother. You do have to be decent.”

To your stepkids: “My kids are here every other weekend. This is still your home, and your room is still yours.” If they ask why your kids get something they don't, tell them the real reason, plainly.

Never ask any kid to report on the other house, or to keep a secret from a parent. And don't run down your kids' mom, or your stepkids' dad, in front of any of them. Kids pass things on, and they hear it as being about them. If things with their dad are hard, here's more on getting along with the kids' dad →

What if my teenage stepkid resents my kids?

A teenager who was there first may have lost a lot: a room, quiet, their mom's time, the front seat. Then younger kids show up every other weekend and the house gets loud. Some will go cold, stay in their room, or snap at the little ones.

Don't make the teen the default babysitter. If you need them to watch the little ones, ask, and treat it as a favor, not a duty.
Keep their room theirs. It isn't the overflow on busy weekends.
Say what you see, once: “I know it got a lot louder around here. Your room's off limits to the little ones. Tell me if that changes.”
Hold the same line on how people are treated. “You don't have to hang out with them. You can't call him that.” Then let their mom follow up.

And keep one thing that's just the teenager and their mom. More on being a stepdad to a teenager →

How do my partner and I talk it through?

Pick a calm time each week, away from the kids. Start with what you saw, not what she did wrong: “When my son and yours both broke the rule Saturday, I think they got different answers. Can we decide what happens next time?” Agree on rules, who handles what, and touchy things like gifts, money and holidays before they come up.

Expect that each of you will see your own kids more kindly. Saying that out loud to each other can make it easier to catch. If you keep getting stuck, a family counselor who works with stepfamilies can help you both. If a kid is ever unsafe at either house, that's a matter for the parents, the courts or the authorities, not something to handle alone.

Is there something to try this week?

Write the house rules down with your partner tonight, five or six of them, and tell the kids together.
Put one short, regular slot on the calendar for each kid, yours and hers.
The next time a kid says you play favorites, ask “Tell me when” and listen to the whole answer.

Not sure where to start?

The free quiz for dads takes about a minute: pick what's hardest right now and get one thing to try tonight. The Better Father is about ten minutes a day, in four versions by your kid's age: 0 to 5, 6 to 13, 14 to 19, and 20 and up. It's $149 once. Full refund within 14 days of buying. Just email us. You don't have to explain or show your log. See the four versions →

Stepdad with kids of your own: how to be fair to your kids and your stepkids