The Better Father Free quiz
For stepdads and dads-to-be in a new family

How to be a good stepdad: go slow, back her up, find your thing

You love their mom, and you want the kids to like you. Some days they do. Other days you get the cold shoulder, or “you're not my dad.” Here's what helps, especially in the first couple of years.

What's hardest right now? Take the 1-minute quizFree. One thing to try tonight. No email needed.

By ·

The short answer

Go slow: expect a close relationship to take years, not months. Don't take over discipline early; let their mom (or dad) lead on rules and consequences while you back her up. Agree on the house rules together, in private. Find one thing you and each stepkid do together, regularly, that's yours. Never compete with or run down their other parent. And keep showing up, the same way, even when they push you away.

What's the biggest mistake new stepdads make?

Moving too fast. Usually with good intentions: you want to be part of the family, so you start making rules, giving advice, and expecting hugs. To the kids, a lot changed at once, and they didn't choose any of it. A new adult telling them what to do can feel like one more thing taken away.

Think of the first year or two as earning trust, not taking a role. Be friendly, reliable and around. Let them come toward you at their own speed. Younger kids often warm up faster; teenagers can take much longer, and that's normal.

Should a stepdad discipline his stepkids?

Not at first, not as the main one. Early on, discipline works best coming from their own parent. Your part is to back her up, calmly and in the same direction.

  • Agree on the rules together, in private. Bedtime, screens, chores, how people talk to each other. Then she tells the kids.
  • Enforce the house rules like any trusted adult would. A sitter or a coach can say “Not in the house, the ball goes outside.” You can too. It's the bigger calls, like grounding or taking the phone, that should come from her for now.
  • When she's not there, hold the rules you've both agreed on, then tell her what happened and let her handle anything bigger.
  • Never undercut her in front of the kids, and ask her not to undercut you. Disagree later, alone.

As trust builds, often over a couple of years, you can take on more. Talk with your partner about when and how. How to discipline without yelling →

How do I back up my partner without taking over?

Stand next to her, not in front of her. When a rule gets broken, let her speak first. If she asks for your help, give it. Afterward, alone, tell her what you saw and how you'd like to handle it next time. Kids test the new adult and look for a gap between the two of you. Keep the gap closed.

How do I build a relationship with my stepson or stepdaughter?

Find one thing you do together. Not a big outing to win them over; a small, regular thing. Shooting hoops, a video game, working on a bike, cooking Sunday breakfast, driving them to practice. Let them pick, or notice what they already like and offer to join.

  • Do it often. Weekly beats a big day once a season.
  • Talk side by side. Kids, and stepkids especially, talk more when you're both looking at something else.
  • Don't push affection. A fist bump is fine. Let them decide on hugs.
  • Let them call you what they want. Your first name is fine. Don't ask for “Dad.”
  • Show up for their things. Games, school plays, the science fair. Sit in the stands even if you're not sure they want you there.

With a stepson, the side-by-side part matters a lot. With a teenage stepdaughter, be warm, respectful of her privacy, and a little more reserved; let her set the pace.

What about their dad?

Don't compete with him and don't criticize him, in front of the kids or where they can hear. Even if they complain about him. Even if you think he's earned it. Kids feel torn when the adults around them take sides, and they often defend the parent who's being criticized.

You can tell them plainly: “I'm not trying to replace your dad. I'm just another person in your corner.” If he's not in the picture, the same goes: no running him down. Let them hold whatever they feel about him. For the other side: staying close as a part-time dad →

What do I say when they say “you're not my dad”?

Agree, calmly. “You're right, I'm not. I'm not trying to be. The rule's still the rule in this house.” Or, if it's not about a rule: “I know. I'm still glad I get to be around you.” Then drop it. It's usually said in a hard moment to see if you'll leave or blow up. Doing neither is the answer.

What if I have kids of my own too?

Keep the rules the same for everyone in the house, and say so. Kids watch closely for favorites. Give your own kids some time alone with you, and give your stepkids time alone with their mom; they need that too.

What if it's going badly?

Many stepfamilies have a rough first stretch. Make time to talk with your partner about the kids when nobody's upset, and keep the two of you on the same page. A family counselor who works with stepfamilies can help you both. If anyone is ever unsafe at home, call 911.

Is there something to do today?

Pick one stepkid and one small thing: “Want to help me fix the bike Saturday?” or “I'm driving to get tacos, come?” Do it this week. Tonight, talk with your partner and agree on one house rule you'll both hold the same way, with her as the one who says it to the kids.

Not sure where to start?

The free quiz for dads takes about a minute: pick what's hardest right now and get one thing to try tonight. The Better Father is about ten minutes a day, in four versions by your kid's age, and it works the same whether you came into their life at birth or at ten. It's $149 once. Full refund within 14 days of buying. Just email us. You don't have to explain or show your log. See the four versions →

More guides for dads